Another committee is not the answer.

Higher education does not have a shortage of committees.

So, when a data governance program needs to bring people together, the instinct is to add another.

Here is a sequence you may recognize. Your sponsor said yes. You draft a charter, ask each vice president to name a representative, and send the calendar invitation. The first meeting is full. People are polite, maybe even curious.

By the third meeting, half the seats are empty. Some representatives send a delegate, and the delegates start sending delegates. The agenda has become a list of updates, and the people who could tell you where the data problems live were never invited in the first place.

Nothing went wrong with the invitation. The problem is that the group was convened to inform, not to decide.

What convening looks like in higher education

Convening, the C in SCALE, is less about forming a group than about forming the right one. The groups that last tend to share three traits:

  • They include the people who do the work.

    Every unit has the person everyone goes to when the numbers need fixing: the analyst who reconciles enrollment every fall, the HR specialist who knows which job codes no longer mean what they say. They know where the problems live. A council made up only of titles will spend its time discovering what those people already know.

  • They have decisions to make.

    People make time for work that matters and drift away from meetings that do not. A group that approves definitions, resolves conflicts between units, and sets priorities gives its members a reason to protect the hour. A group that only receives updates stops showing up by spring.

  • They know what they own, and what they do not.

    Fuzzy decision rights are where turf battles start. When a dean's office and the registrar disagree about who defines a student record, the group needs to decide whether to settle that question or escalate it to the sponsor. Naming that line early saves months of circular conversation.

The part most of us skip

Here is what I see missed most often, even at institutions with a strong sponsor and a thoughtful charter: They put everyone in one room and expect it to both decide and do the work.

Convening usually means two groups, not one: a small council with the standing to decide, and a working group of data stewards who do the work and bring recommendations forward.

Three principles keep that structure from collapsing back into one more committee:

  1. Keep the deciding group small. [Groups of 50+ stewards always become a set of smaller working groups in my experience.]

    If everyone who might be affected has a seat, the council becomes an audience. Aim for a group that is small enough that every member speaks at every meeting, and senior enough that its decisions hold.

  2. Separate deciding from doing.

    Stewards draft definitions, test them against real reports, and surface conflicts. The council weighs in on what the stewards bring forward. Asking a council to wordsmith a data definition wastes senior time, and asking stewards to settle a cross-unit dispute puts them in an impossible spot.

    That split also shapes the second half of convening: the message. Council members need the bird's-eye view (what was decided, why it matters, and what you need from them), while stewards need the nitty-gritty of the definition, the exception, and the report it changes. Swap the two, and you lose both rooms!

  3. Close the loop every time.

    People return when they can see their input became something. Keep a simple decision log, share it after every meeting, and point to it when a decision shows up in a report people use. It is the cheapest retention tool you have.

A group that sees its decisions show up in the work will keep coming. One that hears updates but never sees results will send a delegate, and then no one.

Bonus: If you've read Beyond Tools and Technology: Why Culture-Focused Leadership Matters to Successful Data Governance, the EDUCAUSE Review piece Jason Simon and I wrote, you may recognize the first trait above. It is the caretaker: the person everyone goes to when things need to get done, and the person most likely to be overlooked when the invitations go out.

Coming in January: From Assessment to Action

Convening is where Stewardship & Accountability, one of the five pillars I work through with institutions, starts to take shape. That is why the course pairs it with Leadership & Sponsorship.

In January, I am running a three-week online course that walks through all five pillars, using the SCALE framework (Sponsor, Convene, Align, Learn, Evaluate) to turn an honest assessment of where your institution stands into an executable roadmap. Live sessions on three consecutive Fridays (January 15, 22, and 29), capped at 25 so there is room for real discussion about your institution rather than the general case.

It is called From Assessment to Action: Build a Data Governance Program People Actually Adopt. Enrollment is open now through January 11. Watch the preview.

Four questions worth asking before you send the invitations

Before you convene anyone, it is worth being honest with yourself about the answers to these:

  1. Who fixes the data when it breaks?

    Those are the people who belong in your working group, whatever their titles. If you do not know their names yet, that is your first task.

  2. What will this group decide in its first ninety days?

    If you cannot name two or three real decisions, the group will fill its time with updates. Give it something to settle before the first meeting.

  3. Who is most likely to say no, and are they in the room?

    Skeptics left outside become hallway critics. Inviting them early gives their objections a place to land while you can still use them.

  4. What does this group own, and what goes to the sponsor?

    Write the line down before the first disagreement, not during it. It is far easier to agree on the rules before anyone has something at stake.

The uncomfortable part

The people you most need at the table often have the least room on their calendars. The caretakers are already carrying their units and convening asks more of them.

That does not mean you leave them out. It means you ask your sponsor to protect their time, say plainly what the work will require, and make sure it counts as part of their job rather than sitting on top of it. A steward who is expected to do governance after hours will not be a(n) (active) steward for long.

Who you convene, and what you ask of them, says more about how seriously the institution takes this work than any charter will.

Where does your institution stand?

If the four questions above were hard to answer, that is useful information. The free Data Governance Readiness Assessment takes about ten minutes and scores your institution across all five pillars, including Stewardship & Accountability, with a plain-language breakdown of where to focus first. No consultant, no lengthy report. Just a clear, honest starting point.

Until next time,

Melissa

Next
Next

Your sponsor said yes. Now what?